The Courage of Conviction

[unable to display graphic]

I have been teaching a course in Critical Thinking that finishes this week and it has been a lot of fun. I love questioning status quo thinking, challenging conclusions, discovering underlying assumptions, recognizing bias, and helping students to realize that knowledge is always an approximation. However–I would hate for them to go away from the class having fallen into the trap of relativism, which is NOT the same thing as critical thinking. It is important for leaders to know the difference.

Relativism is the notion that there is no reality outside our own skulls. All perceptions are of equal value because there is no ultimate standard by which to measure perception and, even if there were, there would be no way to get at it because we are dependent on our imperfect human faculties.

A simple example can easily disprove this. I was at the airport in Santiago, Chile. We were waiting for the pilot to complete whatever pilots do so we could back out and start down the runway. Suddenly, I jumped because I perceived that the plane was moving forward and would crash into the terminal in front of us. In fact, however, it was the plane next to us that was pulling out which gave me the sensation that we were moving forward.

My perception was wrong. Now, if someone’s perception can be wrong, that means there is a right. Though all perceptions are approximations, not all perceptions are of equal value. Some perceptions more closely align with reality than others do.

This is where leaders with integrity must be willing to defend what is right, even as they simultaneiously open their ideas to the possibility of correction through public dialogue. Critical thinking does not mean that you have to become cynical about truth. It means you are willing to engage in public discussion. I see three leadership values that must not be lost in our pursuit of critical thinking: passion, conviction, and courage.

  1. Passion is the ability to engage your message emotionally. Leaders are not cold, calculating, or robotic, characters who only engage the mind. They are able to engage both the mind and the emotions without becoming enslaved by either.
  2. Conviction is moral certitude about your message. While absolute certainty is the prerogative of God alone, moral certainty is what happens when we have enough evidence to commit.
  3. Courage is the willingness to stand up for your convictions. The world needs leaders who are willing to go against the grain when truth and consensus are not the same thing or when evil is present. Tolerance is wrong when it mean tolerance of evil.

But, you might be asking, isn’t this dangerous? Isn’t there a danger that passion could overpower reason? Isn’t there a danger that conviction could blind us to disconfirming data? Isn’t there a danger that courage could rob us of legitimate caution?

Yes

Table. Impression Management Versus Courage

Impression Management Moral Courage
Political Correctness Integrity
Conformity to the collective Conformity to the truth
Follow your interests Follow God’s intersts
Seek to dominate See to serve
Clay in the hands of change Clay in the hands of God
Deny existence of evil Expose and resist evil
Deny failure and cover it up Confess failure
Go along Be an agent of change
Constrained by political correctness constrained by truth
Shut the mouths of opposition Encourage robust yet civil dialogue
Self-sufficiency Sufficient in God

Notes

Photo by Author

2 thoughts on “The Courage of Conviction

  1. You said,

    “But, you might be asking, isn’t this dangerous? Isn’t there a danger that passion could overpower reason? Isn’t there a danger that conviction could blind us to disconfirming data? Isn’t there a danger that courage could rob us of legitimate caution?”

    These things are only possible if the Leader’s focus shifts off of God and his or her constituents and onto themselves. Blindness, lack of reasoning, and lack of caution all stem from an over-confidence in one’s abilities.

  2. Jered.

    I agree it is a question of shifting focus. It’s important, nonetheless, to understand that inherent within these very strengths–courage, conviction, and passion–lie the seeds of their own self-destruction. This should motivate us to draw hard after God and also seek the counsel of many.

    Thanks Jered for stopping by.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s